Table of contents
Scope
2.2. Roads PPP is a well-documented subject, both as it concerns best practices and case studies authored by private and public entities and multilateral finance institutions, specifically. However, what has largely been absent in the documentation are the ‘bad practices’: well-intended, but counter-productive practices or ill-intended practices which have achieved their objective, often exploiting loopholes in legislation, tender procedures or PPP agreements. The primary reason for the absence of analyses of bad practices is that many reports are conceived as success stories celebrating achievements – bad practices leading to sub-optimal outcomes or outright failures are preferred to be left untold.
2.3. This project aims to rally support from both public and private PPP practitioners, the academic society and major stakeholders to document best practice to arrive at comprehensive standards serving as an effective tools for governments to successfully navigate through the complexity of PPP programs.
2.4. The sub-categories that will be considered will include national, local international roads and all types of contracts, such as DBFMO, Toll, Shadow Toll, BOT, BOOT and other. Depending on the characteristics and nature of roads (national, local and internationally) appropriate model(s) will be identified during the process of developing standards.
2.5. The Public Private Partnership (PPP) scope will use as a point of reference the United Nations’ definition of PPP, which can be found in the "Guidebook on Promoting Good Governance on PPP".
Project leader & editor
| Position | Name |
|---|---|
| Project leader | |
| Editor |
Project information
| Stage status | ODP Stage | ODP Name | Stage start date | Stage end date | Meetings / Minutes | Relevant documents |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | 1 | Project initiation | 1 February 2015 | 28 February 2015 | ||
| 2 | Stakeholder mobilization | 1 March 2015 | 31 March 2015 | ||
| 3 | Developing initial draft | 1 April 2015 | 31 May 2015 | Meetings & minutes | |
| 4 | Public review | December 2017 | February 2018 | Draft for Public Review version 1.0 (November, 2017) Comments Log • Comments Template for comments and observations • Template | |
| 5 | Endorsement | 20 November 2018 | 20 November 2018 | Meetings & report | Version endorsed by the Working Party on PPPs |
| 6 | Approval | 27 March 2019 | 27 March 2019 | Meetings & report | |
| 7 | Maintenance |
Extra budgetary resources
Trust Fund Amount |
|
|---|---|
Description |
|
Budget Summary |
|
Support
| Country | Focal Point | Organization / Company |
|---|---|---|
| Belarus | Dzmitry Berazouski | Head of the PPP Unit, Ministry of Economy |
| Netherlands | Andri van Mens | Senior Policy Officer Infrastructure, Ministry of Foreign Affairs |
| Russian Federation | Hafiz Salikov | vice-Chairperson, TOS PPP |
Meetings
Relevant documents
References
Contacts and members
Team Members - Roads Alfredo Lucente Team Leader Partner Rome, ITALY +39 06 44 063 215 Email: Alfredo.Lucente@lucente.it Experience: Alfredo Lucente is an expert of all the main fields of law peculiar to the infrastructure, transportation, energy, oil&gas and petrochemical industry in Italy and abroad. His 32 years professional career in this field internationally is without equal. Alfredo Lucente specializes in the representation of clients in the infrastructure, energy, transportation, oil&gas, petrochemical, defense and utilities sectors transactions throughout Southern Europe, other Mediterranean countries, Africa and the Middle East. Alfredo worked from 1982 until 1988 at Technipetrol (now Technip Italy) legal department and from 1988 until 1994 at the law firm Carnelutti. He has developed a substantial practice in the areas of major projects, public procurement, privatizations, construction, international joint ventures and PPP / PFI projects with specific focus on transportation, petrochemical, power and energy projects (particularly in Middle East, Africa, Europe, Latin America). Since 1995 Alfredo Lucente was a lawyer at Baker & McKenzie and practiced internationally with focus in EMEA countries. Alfredo Lucente advices clients on public law matters and represents clients before Administrative Courts and Arbitration Panels particularly in the field of engineering, transportation, energy and environment. Solid experience gained by working in different places in different international countries and in complex environment including Nigeria, Algeria, Libya, Egypt, Morocco, Mozambique, Somali, Senegal, Iraq, Kuwait, Syria, Iran, Egypt, Qatar, Turkey, Greece, Albania, etc. Naresh BANA Area of Work: Founder and Managing Director BBV Consultants LLP (www.bbvconsultants.com) Founding Member and Executive Vice Chairman Indo – Sri Lanka Chamber of Commerce and Industry (www.iscci.org.in ) Country: India Experience: Naresh Bana, F.I.E., M.I.M.A., M.I.P.W.E., is an engineering professional with adequate industry experience. An Infrastructure man, his professional career can be divided into four distinct phases. The first twenty years spent in evolving into a self initiated, quality conscious, innovative and dependable senior engineer and leader. Next three years in leadership role in Kashmir Rail Project where his capacities got recognized not only at organizational but also at the National level. He then got a challenging assignment for two years as head of planning for a large road building company of India. Having excelled at the assigned responsibilities and further honing skills at Harvard Business School, he moved on to set up and lead an infrastructure consultancy in New Delhi. An engineer, businessman and leader, he has adequate reach in Government, Industry, IGO and NGO sector. Doris Chevalier Area of Work: Private Operator Country: France Experience: A number of projects in France, Germany, Iraq, Iran, India, Kazakhstan, Spain, UK Country Year Type of contract Expertise provided Australia 2014 PPP contract for construction, operation & maintenance of SYDNEY CBD LRT Contractual and finance France 2012 2015 Concession Contract Tours Bordeaux Concession Contract Reims LRT Public finance and contractual, in charge of French state guarantee implementation Board member Italy 2015 PPP contract for Milan L5 Metro Contractual and finance Pekka Leviakangas Area of Work: Academia Country: Finland Experience: Country Year Type of contract Expertise provided EU 2014-2016 H2020 research contract Policy and business advice through railway PPP research analysis Finland, Sweden, Germany 2013 Bothnian Green Logistic Corridor – consulting contract Policy and business advice through research analysis EU 2010-2014 Cost action research contract PPP policy advice, financial advice through research analysis Finland 2008-2011 National research contract Governance, financial advice through research analysis Finland, EU 2001-2011 European railway research contracts Governance, financial, policy, liberalization advice through research analysis Finland 1998-2001 Corporate Analyst, Finnish Railways’ investments and corporate finance Financial analysis Sze Wai Pan Chairman,CEO Freetech Road Recycling Technology (Holding) Limited Wan Chai, Hongkong Email: banting-sze@freetech.com.hk Mr. Sze is the founder, Chairman, CEO of Freetech Road Recycling Technology (Holdings) Limited, a company listed on HKEX main board (HK stock code: 6888). Mr. Sze is the chief engineer of Freetech Group, and the expert in asphalt pavement Hot-in-Place recycling technology R&D and engineering management, the pioneer of Green development in China road maintenance industry, and the inventor of approximately 200 national patents. Mr. Sze obtained a Master of Science degree (with distinction) from University of Warwick, United Kingdom, and Master of Arts in Quantitative Analysis for Business in City University of Hong Kong. In May 2009, Mr. Sze was awarded the highest recognition in the field of science and technology as a Nanjing Science and Technology Achievement Award from Nanjing Municipal Government. In March 2013, he was nominated for the Young to Middle-aged Expert with Outstanding Contributions in Jiangsu Province. In March 2017, Mr. Sze received Outstanding ME Alumni Award from the Hong Kong Polytechnic University. Mr. Sze has participated in the State Council counselor meetings and made speeches and suggestions for the green recycling welfare. Fred Amonya Country: United Kingdom Fred is Lead Advisor (Infrastructure Policy) at Lyciar and previously Senior Consultant (PPP) at Mott MacDonald. He has nearly 16 years of experience in infrastructure policy and investment management. This experience covers both research and practice. On the latter, he has advised governments, investment banks, lenders to infrastructure concessions, and infrastructure asset managers drawn from all around the world. While most of his work has been in the roads sector, he has also worked on ports, railways and airports - both developing and developed countries. To this end, he has done policy and institutional analysis, infrastructure deterioration modelling, traffic appraisal, and economic and financial modelling. In respect to research, he addresses the internalisation of science in policymaking, while challenging the existing macroeconomic [endogenous growth] models. In addition, Fred has published widely on the institutional economics of Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) and infrastructure asset management. He is a Chartered Engineer (UK). Experience: Countries Type of contract: Service, management, lease, concession, BOT, others (please specify) Expertise you provided: Policy & governance, contractual, finance, technical UK Management and Concession Contracts Policy and Technical Uganda Pre-Contract Policy and Institutions Egypt Management and Concession Contracts Policy and Technical Ghana Pre-Contract Policy and Institutions UAE (Abu Dhabi) Pre-Contract and Concession Policy and Technical Nigeria Concession Technical France Concession Technical USA Concession Technical Indonesia Concession Technical Vicky D. Kefalas Greece-United States Email: vkefalas@ccc.gr LinkedIn: http://gr.linkedin.com/in/vickykefalas/en Experience: Vicky possesses 22 years of broad finance and project development experience, of which the last 14 years have been mainly in corporate and project finance (concession, BOT and PPP type) projects. Vicky has led the structuring of several multi-million dollar infrastructure projects and has been an integral part in the successful financial closure of many of them. Furthermore, Vicky has assessed over 300 projects and submitted over 150 proposals for investment, including Fire Brigade Stations, Police Headquarters, Motorways, Airports, Marinas, Car Parks, Waste to Energy and Solar plants, spreading across different countries, such as Greece, Romania, Cyprus, Russia, UAE, Kuwait, Egypt, Jordan, Uganda and Kenya. Last, Vicky is an active participant in the PPP and Project Finance space, by attending sector events, undertaking speaking engagements and, overall, by regularly contributing on the positive development of the PPP model as a tool for infrastructure development and sustainable economic growth. Master of Business Administration (MBA) in Finance 1994 Pace University, The Lubin School of Business - New York, USA Bachelor in Economics (BA) 1991 The City University of New York - New York, USA Champika Liyanage Area of Work: Academia Country: United Kingdom Experience: Country Year Type of contract Expertise provided UK 2010-present All types of PPPs Have carried out research relating to Public Private Partnerships since 2010. Have specifically got involved in two EU projects in PPPs in Transportation. Within these projects, have also carried out research relating to the Rail sector. Area of Work: Academia Country: Russian Federation Experience: Svetlana’s experience covers many areas of legislation with a particular emphasizes on international law and public-private partnership. She has been working for 8 years as a Deputy Chairman of the Legal Committee of the Government of St. Petersburg on issues of legal expertise in the field of property relations and investment, including legislation in the field of PPP). During this period Svetlana took part in legal structuring of several large-scale PPP projects, particularly in construction and operation of Pulkovo Airport, Western High-Speed Diameter, Orlovski Tunnel, Perinatal Center, etc. She also was a member of the Working Group on development of the first regional Law on PPP in Russia No. 627-100 from 25.12.2006 “On Participation of St. Petersburg in Public-Private Partnerships”. Other Svetlana’s professional activities include the leadership of the Working Group on PPP in Coordination Council for the Development of the Transport System of St. Petersburg and Leningrad Region and the membership in the Working Group on Regulatory and Methodological Support of PPP Mechanisms Development in Healthcare in the Coordination Council for PPP of the Healthcare Ministry of the Russian Federation. Currently, Svetlana Maslova pays more attention to the research and methodological activity in the field of PPP. Thereby, she is the developer of educational and professional training programs, head of research and expert projects in the field of PPP and the author of more than 30 academic publications and case studies on PPP published in Russian and international sources. During the last year Svetlana also has led the elaboration of UNECE PPP Best Practice Guide in Road Sector. Suresh Chand Mittal Area of Work: IL&FS Transportation Networks Ltd Private Operator Country: India Experience: Country Year Type of contract Expertise provided India 7 Design, Build, Finance, Operation & Maintenance of Metro Rail system on PPP model Technical Mukund Gajanan Sapre Country: India Engineering graduate with close to 35 years of experience, of which the last 16 years have been dedicated to privatization in the Country. Has worked with various governments (Central & State) in setting up legal frameworks in place enabling Private Sector Participation (PSP). Extensive interactions with lenders and multilateral agencies, which have participated in the projects, undertaken as Public Private Partnerships. Also involved in international projects and led the bidding efforts of the company in countries like The Philippines, Indonesia, Mexico, Spain, South Africa, Kenya, Kazakhstan, Botswana, etc. Implementing high speed Rail project in Mexico and evaluating cargo airport project in Mexico. Recently, was instrumental in bidding for the Kathmandu-Tarai Fast Track road project, in Nepal where the company emerged as the Preferred Bidder in an ICB. The key experience has been in delivering of projects from concept to commissioning involving setting up of sustainable legal, financial structures for non-recourse project financing. Presently handling varied responsibilities in multiple roles as Chief Executive Officer, Executive Director and Managing Director. Employment Brief Has been associated with Infrastructure Leasing & Financial Services (IL&FS) since 1992 and later as the head of its subsidiary which was created with a focus on PPP based road Concessions in India – IL&FS Transportation Networks Ltd. (ITNL) since 2000. Was appointed the Managing Director of Elsamex S.A (Spain), a Spanish company taken over by ITNL in 2009. Prior to IL&FS, was in Engineers India Limited (EIL) as Deputy Manager for 8 years. Worked with Gammon India Limited for 4 years before EIL as Assistant Engineer. Félix Villalba University of Central Lancashire Email: fvillalba@uclan.ac.uk / fvillalbaromero@hotmaill.com Experience with transport infrastructure PPPs in Spain and United Kingdom. Type of contract: BOT and research on others. Expertise: Policy and governance, contractual, and finance Alper Akar Turkey Yeva Akrachkova Kazakhastan Marcel Babczynski Czech Republic Daniel Bauer United States Anuj Chabra UAE Ekow Coleman Serdar Dayan Turkey Colin Duffield Australia Alma Issina Kazakhstan Romain Limouzin Aristeidis Pantelias United Kingdom Ozgur Pehlivan Turkey Mohammad Abu Rashed Bangladesh Athena Roumboutsos Greece Sholpan Sapargali Kazakhstan Sonal Shah United Kingdom Nikolay Stankov Bulgaria Lourdes Trujillo Andrey Yushkov Russian FederationProject leader & editor
Project leader Editor 
| Position | Name |
|---|---|
| Project leader | Alfredo LUCENTE |
| Editor | |
| Members | User list not rendered as you do not have the privilege to view user profiles. |